Did Smart Balance buttery spread (Conagra) change its recipe?

United States · 2022 · Watered down (less oil or fat)

Yes, according to mouseprint.org. Oil share: 64% → 39% (United States, dated 2022 by the source). ShrinkRadar logs this as a recipe downgrade, kept separate from size cuts.

Recipe Facts
Recipe change reportedYes
What changedoil share
Before64%
After39%
Dated (by the source)2022
CountryUnited States
BrandSmart Balance

After thousands of one-star reviews Conagra brought the original recipe back in 2023 (Mouse Print, August 2023).

What the source says

“now it is only 39-percent oil”

From More Groceries Hit By “Skimpflation” — Part 1 – Mouse Print*, reported 2022-09-26. Consumer advocate report (Mouse Print*, old and new labels compared).

More recipe changes

See all 30 recipe changes. Spotted a cheaper recipe? Send it in with the old and new ingredient lists.

FAQ

Did Smart Balance buttery spread (Conagra) change its recipe?

Yes. Oil share went from 64% → 39% (United States, dated 2022), according to mouseprint.org.

Is this shrinkflation?

Not exactly. Shrinkflation is a smaller net quantity on the label. This entry is about what is inside: a recipe or material downgrade, often called skimpflation. Where the pack also got smaller, that size cut is listed separately in the case library. ShrinkRadar logs these separately and never counts them as size cuts or in the ShrinkRadar Index.